Plate with hole (symmetry planes via normal constraints)
StaticPASS · 1.38%Stress concentration factor (Kirsch problem) for a tensioned plate with a central hole, solved on a quarter-symmetry model using surface normal constraints (n·u = 0) vs full model.
- Tolerance:
- 5%
Open & Solve in BrowserSign in or register to launch this verified model in WebCAE
Open & Solve in BrowserProblem statement
- Geometry
- Square plate 200 × 200 × 5 mm with circular hole of radius R = 20 mm. Quarter model: 100 × 100 × 5 mm domain.
- Material
- Structural steel: E = 200 GPa, ν = 0.3.
- Boundary conditions
- Normal constraint (n·u = 0) on symmetry planes x = 0 and y = 0; uniform tension σ0 = 100 MPa on outer edge x = 100 mm; z = 0 clamped to prevent rigid drift.
- Measured quantity
- Peak von Mises stress σ_max at the hole edge (r = R). Quarter-symmetry model yields 325.06 MPa vs full plate 320.62 MPa (deviation 1.38%). Normal constraint on planar symmetry faces matches global axis fixations to exact machine precision (Δu = 0.00%).
WebCAE Terminal
Paste these commands into the Terminal panel inside WebCAE. They use the same text DSL as the application; run one command per line:
material E=200000000000 nu=0.3
fix "face" "surface number 8" component="normal" value=0
fix "face" "surface number 9" component="normal" value=0
fix "face" "surface number 6" component="z" value=0
load "face" "surface number 2" distributed_force=100000000 component="x"
solve
probe "vonMises" target=320620000 tolerance=5 id="KIRSCH-PLATE-HOLE-SIGMA-MAX" units="Pa" source="Full plate FEA / Kirsch stress concentration"Script source
[
{ "cmd": "SetMaterial", "E": 2e11, "nu": 0.3 },
{ "cmd": "AddBoundaryCondition", "element": "displacement", "component": "normal", "value": 0, "target": "surface number 8" },
{ "cmd": "AddBoundaryCondition", "element": "displacement", "component": "normal", "value": 0, "target": "surface number 9" },
{ "cmd": "AddBoundaryCondition", "element": "displacement", "component": "z", "value": 0, "target": "surface number 6" },
{ "cmd": "AddLoad", "element": "distributed_force", "component": "x", "value": 1e8, "target": "surface number 2" },
{ "cmd": "RunSolve" },
{
"cmd": "ExtractResult",
"id": "KIRSCH-PLATE-HOLE-SIGMA-MAX",
"quantity": "vonMises",
"at": { "r": 0.02 },
"target": 3.2062e8,
"tolerancePercent": 5,
"units": "Pa",
"source": "Full plate FEA / Kirsch stress concentration"
}
]Results comparison
| Reference value | 320.62 MPa |
| Our result | 325.06 MPa |
| Deviation | 1.38% |
| Tolerance | 5% |
| Status | PASS · 1.38% |
| Element family | Solid element |
| Mesh details | Quarter mesh 1125 nodes / 4032 tets (full 4320 nodes / 16128 tets) |
Updated: 2026-08-06 · before version numbering (before 0.1.1)