Verification
WebCAE is checked against publicly documented benchmark suites used for finite-element verification. The catalog below separates named external references from work that is still in development; real results appear only after an actual solver run.
Methodology
MacNeal–Harder
A recognized element and shell benchmark suite covering patch behavior, mesh distortion, bending, twisting and locking sensitivity.
NAFEMS
The de-facto industry standard, with reference values across static, thermal, modal and buckling problems.
Element families
Each published result identifies whether it was solved with solid, shell, beam or finite-volume CFD elements, so the catalog reflects the actual physical modeling approach.
Nonlinear mechanics, Contact & CFD (SU2)
The catalog verifies not only linear statics, but also geometric nonlinearity (large displacements, Crisfield arc-length snap-through), nonlinear Mortar contact and computational fluid dynamics problems (SU2_CFD).
Mathematical Formulations & Degrees of Freedom
In-depth guide to all 13 structural solver element types (IDs 1–13), SU2 CFD dual polyhedra, quadrature schemes, and locking alleviation.
Reference cases
| Case | Discipline | What it checks | Source | Tolerance | Element family | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patch test | Static | Baseline element correctness on a coarse, irregular mesh | MacNeal–Harder benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| NAFEMS LE1 | Static | Elliptical membrane — stress concentration | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 3.62% |
| NAFEMS FV2 | Modal analysis | Natural frequencies of a flat plate | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 1.2% |
| Cantilever beam (Euler-Bernoulli) | Static | Tip deflection of a slender cantilever under a distributed load | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.03% |
| Cantilever beam (Timoshenko) | Static | Tip deflection of a stocky beam including shear deformation | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.29% |
| Hertzian contact (sphere) | Static | Nonlinear contact, Hertzian pressure distribution | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.67% |
| Semi-infinite solid — transient | Thermal conduction | Transient conduction, error-function solution | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.32% |
| Curved beam | Static | In-plane and out-of-plane response of a curved cantilever | MacNeal–Harder benchmark suite | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 1.44% |
| NAFEMS LE3 | Static (shells) | Hemispherical shell under point loads | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.13% |
| NAFEMS LE10 | Static | Thick plate under pressure — bending stress | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.67% |
| NAFEMS LE11 | Static | Thermal stress in a solid of revolution | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 4.88% |
| NAFEMS FV5 | Modal analysis | Deep simply supported beam — repeated eigenvalues, shear and rotary inertia | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 3.49% |
| NAFEMS T3 | Thermal conduction | 1D transient conduction with a time-dependent boundary | NAFEMS thermal benchmark suite | 5% | — | PASS · 0.04% |
| B-Rep Stiffened Sheet Panel with 9 Imprinted Stringers and Frames | Statics (beam-shell CAD) | B-Rep quad-sheet panel 3000 × 1500 × 4 mm with 9 imprinted stiffener lines (4 stringers, 5 frames, 49 tee beams on common nodes) under 0.002 MPa pressure: clamped Timoshenko plate verification and 100x stiffness enhancement verification. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 2.55% |
| Stiffened Fuselage Barrel Transverse Bending and Bredt-Batho Torsion | Statics (beam-shell) | Cantilever transverse bending (V = 50 kN) and Bredt-Batho torsion (T = 100 kN·m) of an aircraft fuselage section with 96 stringers and 15 frames: tip deflection, crown stress, twist angle, and shear stress verified against composite section Steiner and Bredt-B… show full textCantilever transverse bending (V = 50 kN) and Bredt-Batho torsion (T = 100 kN·m) of an aircraft fuselage section with 96 stringers and 15 frames: tip deflection, crown stress, twist angle, and shear stress verified against composite section Steiner and Bredt-Batho formulas. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 1.46% |
| Stiffened Fuselage Barrel Natural Flexural Vibrations | Modal Analysis (beam-shell) | First natural flexural vibration frequency of an aircraft fuselage barrel reinforced by 96 stringers and 15 frames: verified against a 1D Timoshenko beam model accounting for shear deformation, rotatory inertia, and distributed stringer mass. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 1.63% |
| Fuselage Barrel Internal Pressurization with 96 Smeared Stringers | Statics (beam-shell) | Internal pressurization (dp = 0.06 MPa) of a cylindrical aircraft fuselage section (D = 3.9 m, L = 7.0 m, t = 1.8 mm) reinforced by 96 tee stringers: axial stress, radial expansion, and hoop stress verified against Lamé-Barlow shell theory with smeared stringe… show full textInternal pressurization (dp = 0.06 MPa) of a cylindrical aircraft fuselage section (D = 3.9 m, L = 7.0 m, t = 1.8 mm) reinforced by 96 tee stringers: axial stress, radial expansion, and hoop stress verified against Lamé-Barlow shell theory with smeared stringer area. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.01% |
| Pressurized Space Station Module with Stiffened Shell and Truss | Statics & Dynamics (beam-shell) | Cabin atmospheric pressurization (dp = 101.3 kPa, 1 atm) and cantilever dynamic frequency of a space station pressurized module (D = 4.2 m, L = 8.4 m, skin t = 4 mm) stiffened by 24 longitudinal stringers, ring frames, and integrated truss segment: hoop stress… show full textCabin atmospheric pressurization (dp = 101.3 kPa, 1 atm) and cantilever dynamic frequency of a space station pressurized module (D = 4.2 m, L = 8.4 m, skin t = 4 mm) stiffened by 24 longitudinal stringers, ring frames, and integrated truss segment: hoop stress, axial stress, radial expansion, and fundamental bending mode verified against Lamé thin shell theory and Timoshenko beam theory. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.11% |
| Ship Hull Deck Panel Buckling and Eccentric Stiffener Strip Bending | Buckling & Statics (beam-shell) | Elastic bifurcation buckling of an isolated ship deck panel (3.0 × 1.167 m, t = 18 mm) bounded by transverse web frames and longitudinal stiffeners under uniaxial compression verified against Bryan's classical plate formula, along with composite bending of an… show full textElastic bifurcation buckling of an isolated ship deck panel (3.0 × 1.167 m, t = 18 mm) bounded by transverse web frames and longitudinal stiffeners under uniaxial compression verified against Bryan's classical plate formula, along with composite bending of an eccentric tee bottom longitudinal strip verified against Steiner parallel axis theorem. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 1.36% |
| Stiffened Ship Hull Stillwater and Wave Bending | Statics (beam-shell) | Global longitudinal bending of a 180 m cargo ship hull (180 × 28 × 16.5 m, draft T = 10.5 m, displacement 48,099 t) reinforced by longitudinal and transverse stiffeners: midship vertical deflection, deck stress, and bottom stress in stillwater and sagging wave… show full textGlobal longitudinal bending of a 180 m cargo ship hull (180 × 28 × 16.5 m, draft T = 10.5 m, displacement 48,099 t) reinforced by longitudinal and transverse stiffeners: midship vertical deflection, deck stress, and bottom stress in stillwater and sagging wave verified against Timoshenko hull girder beam theory with shear flow correction. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.37% |
| Skyscraper Reinforced Concrete Core and Outrigger Wind Response | Statics & Dynamics (beam-shell) | Wind load drift, base overturning bending stress, gravity dead-weight settlement, and fundamental cantilever natural frequency of a 288 m high-rise building core (13.5 × 13.5 m, t = 0.6 m, 2 internal shear walls) and outrigger truss frame: verified against Tim… show full textWind load drift, base overturning bending stress, gravity dead-weight settlement, and fundamental cantilever natural frequency of a 288 m high-rise building core (13.5 × 13.5 m, t = 0.6 m, 2 internal shear walls) and outrigger truss frame: verified against Timoshenko flexure-shear beam theory and Dunkerley frequency formula. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 1.34% |
| Cantilever shell strip with eccentric rectangular rib (Steiner theorem) | Statics (beam-shell) | Cantilever plate strip stiffened by an eccentric rectangular rib: composite section bending stiffness verified against the Steiner parallel axis theorem and flush-in/flush-out sign invariance. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.07% |
| Cantilever shell strip with eccentric tee rib (Steiner theorem) | Statics (beam-shell) | Bending of a cantilever shell strip stiffened by a tee stringer with its flange flush to the skin: centroid offset and composite section inertia verified against analytical Steiner formulation and concentric baseline. | Analytical composite beam-shell theory (Steiner / Timoshenko / Bredt–Batho) | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.09% |
| Annular Aerospike Plug Nozzle Axial Thrust & Throat Acceleration | Rocket Propulsion Aerodynamics (CFD) | Axial aerodynamic force, annular throat acceleration, and truncated base wake recirculation for an altitude-compensating annular aerospike plug nozzle with 6 cooling pylon struts. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.07% |
| API 6A High-Pressure Gate Valve Throttling Resistance | Valve Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Internal hydrodynamic throttling and pressure drop across a partially closed (~35% open) API 6A gate valve under high-pressure water flow, verified against API standard resistance coefficients and Idelchik handbook. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 0.77% |
| Backward-Facing Step Flow at Re = 400 (Armaly et al. Benchmark) | Internal Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Laminar flow separation, recirculation bubble, and sudden expansion pressure recovery over a backward-facing step (step height S = 5 mm, expansion ratio ER = 2.0) at Reynolds number Re = 400, verified against the benchmark of Armaly et al. and the Borda-Carnot… show full textLaminar flow separation, recirculation bubble, and sudden expansion pressure recovery over a backward-facing step (step height S = 5 mm, expansion ratio ER = 2.0) at Reynolds number Re = 400, verified against the benchmark of Armaly et al. and the Borda-Carnot sudden expansion theory. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 2.37% |
| Plane Slit Channel Laminar Flow (Poiseuille Flow) | Internal Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Laminar flow of air in a narrow flat slit channel of height H = 2 mm, width W = 50 mm, and length L = 200 mm at Reynolds number Re_H = 137, verified against the analytical plane Poiseuille pressure drop Delta p = 12*mu*L*U / H^2. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 0.32% |
| Circular Cylinder Crossflow at Re = 40 (Tritton & Coutanceau-Bouard Benchmark) | External Aerodynamics (CFD) | Steady 3D laminar crossflow over a circular cylinder of diameter D = 5 mm in a wind tunnel domain at Reynolds number Re = 40, verified against the classical experimental and numerical drag benchmark of Tritton, Coutanceau & Bouard, and Henderson (Cd = 1.580 wi… show full textSteady 3D laminar crossflow over a circular cylinder of diameter D = 5 mm in a wind tunnel domain at Reynolds number Re = 40, verified against the classical experimental and numerical drag benchmark of Tritton, Coutanceau & Bouard, and Henderson (Cd = 1.580 with tunnel blockage correction). | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.89% |
| Reusable Rocket Booster 3×3 Lattice Grid Fin Normal Force & Braking Drag | Launch Vehicle External Aerodynamics (CFD) | Aerodynamic braking drag, normal control lift force, and inter-cell channel flow acceleration for a 3×3 cellular titanium rocket grid fin at 12° angle of attack. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.13% |
| Hagen-Poiseuille Circular Pipe Laminar Flow (Re = 100) | Internal Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Steady laminar incompressible flow of air through a straight circular pipe of diameter D = 10 mm and length L = 200 mm at Reynolds number Re = 100, verified against the analytical Hagen-Poiseuille parabolic velocity profile u_max / U_mean = 2.0. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 2.51% |
| LRE Coaxial Swirl Injector Chamber & De Laval Nozzle Mass Balance | Rocket Propulsion Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Three-inlet mass conservation and converging-diverging De Laval nozzle throat acceleration in a liquid rocket engine chamber with axial oxidizer feed, dual tangential fuel swirl injectors, and a 4-strut flameholder. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 0.62% |
| Ducted Marine Thruster (Kort Nozzle) Hydrodynamic Thrust | Marine Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Hydrodynamic axial thrust and momentum balance for a Kort nozzle ducted marine thruster with 3-blade stator assembly in a towing channel, verified against Kort nozzle momentum theory. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 2.49% |
| Ground-Effect Racing Diffuser Downforce and Pressure Recovery | Motorsport Aerodynamics (CFD) | Aerodynamic downforce and underbody Venturi diffuser pressure recovery for a ground-effect racing chassis with rear wing, verified against ground-effect wind-tunnel benchmark data. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 2.13% |
| LRE Turbopump Axial Helical Inducer & Deswirl Stator Hydrodynamics | Turbomachinery & Rocket Propulsion (CFD) | Axial hydrodynamic thrust, meridional cascade acceleration, and stage pressure differential across a 3-blade helical rocket turbopump inducer (+34°) and 4-vane deswirl stator (−18°) operating on RP-1 kerosene. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.17% |
| Staggered Tube Bundle Cross-Flow Pressure Drop (Zhukauskas Correlation) | Internal Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Cross-flow pressure drop and mass balance across a 5-tube staggered heat exchanger bundle in a rectangular duct, verified against the classical empirical correlation of Zhukauskas. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.57% |
| Dual-Inlet Swirl Mixing Manifold Mass Conservation | Manifold Hydrodynamics (CFD) | Law of conservation of mass and flow-merging hydraulic losses in a dual-inlet mixing manifold with internal swirl baffle, verifying mass flow balance between dual inlets and single reducer outlet. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 0.06% |
| UAV Wing Subsonic Lift and Vortex Shedding (Prandtl Lifting-Line) | External Aerodynamics (CFD) | Subsonic 3D finite wing aerodynamics of a swept tapered UAV wing with upward-canted winglet at 9.5° angle of attack, verified against Prandtl lifting-line theory for finite-span wings. | CFD verification benchmark | 5% | Finite-volume CFD | PASS · 1.55% |
| Thick cylinder prescribed normal expansion | Static | Prescribed non-zero displacement along surface normal (d ≠ 0): thick cylinder expanded radially by d = 50 μm on outer surface, verified against Lamé analytical elasticity. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.24% |
| Geomechanics — Drucker–Prager / Mohr–Coulomb Triaxial Compression & Dilatancy | Geomechanics | Verification of pressure-dependent Drucker–Prager / Mohr–Coulomb plasticity with non-associated dilatancy, smooth cone return, apex return, and consistent 6x6 tangent. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Dynamics: step load on a bar — dynamic amplification factor 2.0 | Implicit transient dynamics | A suddenly applied constant axial force at the free end of a prismatic bar. A continuum bar responds with a sawtooth tip displacement whose peak is exactly twice the static elongation F·L/(E·A) at t = T₁/2 = 2L/c. The 3-D tet10 model with the Newmark trapezoid… show full textA suddenly applied constant axial force at the free end of a prismatic bar. A continuum bar responds with a sawtooth tip displacement whose peak is exactly twice the static elongation F·L/(E·A) at t = T₁/2 = 2L/c. The 3-D tet10 model with the Newmark trapezoid rule must reproduce the factor 2. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.84% |
| Dynamics: two-span beam with eccentric section offset and internal moment hinge (CE) | Implicit transient dynamics | Corotational beam-shell transient dynamics supporting rigid section-centroid offsets (fields 13..18 via transformation T) and internal bending-moment hinge releases (Lagrange-multiplier constraint equations C·u = 0). A clamped-clamped two-span beam with an int… show full textCorotational beam-shell transient dynamics supporting rigid section-centroid offsets (fields 13..18 via transformation T) and internal bending-moment hinge releases (Lagrange-multiplier constraint equations C·u = 0). A clamped-clamped two-span beam with an internal M_z hinge at mid-span deflects exactly 4.0× as much as a continuous clamped-clamped beam and converges to the static solution. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Dynamics: free damped vibration of a cantilever with Rayleigh damping | Implicit transient dynamics | A prismatic steel cantilever is pulled by a tip force and released (initial displacement = static solution, load amplitude 0:0). Rayleigh damping C = a·M + b·K₀ is tuned for ζ = 2 % on the first mode. The logarithmic decrement of the tip displacement and the d… show full textA prismatic steel cantilever is pulled by a tip force and released (initial displacement = static solution, load amplitude 0:0). Rayleigh damping C = a·M + b·K₀ is tuned for ζ = 2 % on the first mode. The logarithmic decrement of the tip displacement and the damped period are compared with δ = 2πζ/√(1−ζ²) and with the first natural period of the native modal analysis of the same mesh. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.07% |
| Dynamics: elastic-plastic bar under a slow pulse — residual strain equals quasi-static unloading | Implicit transient dynamics / plasticity | A steel bar with J2 plasticity and linear isotropic hardening is loaded past yield by a smooth half-sine-squared pulse much longer than its periods and then relaxes under light Rayleigh damping. After the vibrations decay the permanent elongation must equal th… show full textA steel bar with J2 plasticity and linear isotropic hardening is loaded past yield by a smooth half-sine-squared pulse much longer than its periods and then relaxes under light Rayleigh damping. After the vibrations decay the permanent elongation must equal the quasi-static load-unload result of the same mesh and the closed form ε_p = (σ_max − σ_y)(1/E_t − 1/E). The plasticity history is committed at every accepted time step. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.42% |
| Dynamics: HHT-α numerical damping matches the amplification matrix of the scheme | Implicit transient dynamics | Free vibration of a cantilever integrated with the HHT-α method (α = −0.1, β = (1−α)²/4, γ = (1−2α)/2) at a coarse step Δt = T₁/8, where the scheme dissipates visibly. The measured logarithmic decrement per period and the period are compared with the modulus a… show full textFree vibration of a cantilever integrated with the HHT-α method (α = −0.1, β = (1−α)²/4, γ = (1−2α)/2) at a coarse step Δt = T₁/8, where the scheme dissipates visibly. The measured logarithmic decrement per period and the period are compared with the modulus and argument of the dominant complex eigenvalue of the one-step amplification matrix of an undamped oscillator evaluated at Ω = ω₁Δt. The same matrix gives ρ∞ = (1+α)/(1−α) for high-frequency modes. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Dynamics: Newmark trapezoid rule conserves energy over 100 periods | Implicit transient dynamics | Undamped free vibration of a cantilever released from its static deflection, integrated with the Newmark average-acceleration rule (β = 1/4, γ = 1/2) over 100 periods of the first mode. For a linear system this rule conserves the discrete energy, so T + W_int… show full textUndamped free vibration of a cantilever released from its static deflection, integrated with the Newmark average-acceleration rule (β = 1/4, γ = 1/2) over 100 periods of the first mode. For a linear system this rule conserves the discrete energy, so T + W_int − T₀ stays at rounding level while the unconditionally stable but non-dissipative scheme shows no amplitude drift. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Dynamics: seismic base acceleration and RBE2 kinematic constraints in 3D solids | Implicit transient dynamics | Implicit Newmark transient dynamics of a 3D solid cantilever under step base acceleration a₀ = 1 m/s² (−M·ι·a₀(t)) and under remote tip force/moment transmitted through an RBE2 rigid spider (projected via T₀ᵀ M T₀ and T₀ᵀ K T₀). Both web WASM and native solver… show full textImplicit Newmark transient dynamics of a 3D solid cantilever under step base acceleration a₀ = 1 m/s² (−M·ι·a₀(t)) and under remote tip force/moment transmitted through an RBE2 rigid spider (projected via T₀ᵀ M T₀ and T₀ᵀ K T₀). Both web WASM and native solvers reproduce the analytical step dynamic amplification factor DAF = 1.946 relative to the Euler–Bernoulli static deflection. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.05% |
| Euler column buckling across classic boundary conditions suite | Buckling | Comprehensive verification suite for linear elastic bifurcation buckling of slender prismatic columns under all four classical end constraint conditions: hinged–hinged (pinned–pinned, K = 1.0), fixed–free (cantilever, K = 2.0), fixed–pinned (propped cantilever… show full textComprehensive verification suite for linear elastic bifurcation buckling of slender prismatic columns under all four classical end constraint conditions: hinged–hinged (pinned–pinned, K = 1.0), fixed–free (cantilever, K = 2.0), fixed–pinned (propped cantilever, K = 0.69916), and fixed–fixed (clamped–clamped, K = 0.5). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.1% |
| Explicit dynamics: adiabatic heating with Johnson-Cook thermal softening | Explicit dynamics (thermo-plastic coupling) | Adiabatic temperature rise dT = eta * integral(sigma d(eps_p)) / (rho * cp) of copper deformed at 100 1/s, where the flow stress falls with temperature through the Johnson-Cook thermal term. The reference is an independent fourth-order Runge-Kutta integration… show full textAdiabatic temperature rise dT = eta * integral(sigma d(eps_p)) / (rho * cp) of copper deformed at 100 1/s, where the flow stress falls with temperature through the Johnson-Cook thermal term. The reference is an independent fourth-order Runge-Kutta integration of the same ODE; the specific heat is deliberately low (20 J/(kg K)) so that the softening is visible, and the card checks that the reference actually distinguishes the coupling (without softening the rise would be higher). | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.04% |
| Explicit dynamics: bar tension, J2 with linear hardening | Explicit dynamics (material model) | A bar is stretched at a nominal strain rate of 2 1/s by a prescribed face velocity (smooth 0.5 ms start, much longer than the wave transit time). The stress-strain curve and the plastic strain computed by the explicit solver on the shared material-point kernel… show full textA bar is stretched at a nominal strain rate of 2 1/s by a prescribed face velocity (smooth 0.5 ms start, much longer than the wave transit time). The stress-strain curve and the plastic strain computed by the explicit solver on the shared material-point kernel are checked against the closed-form bilinear law. The previous built-in explicit law depended on the number of time steps; this one does not. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Explicit dynamics: Bauschinger effect, mixed and kinematic hardening | Explicit dynamics (material model) | A bar is stretched into the plastic range and reversed. The magnitude of the stress on the reversal branch is checked against the yield-surface translation: the reverse yield stress is sigma_max - 2R, where R = sigma_y + (1 - beta) H eps_p is the radius after… show full textA bar is stretched into the plastic range and reversed. The magnitude of the stress on the reversal branch is checked against the yield-surface translation: the reverse yield stress is sigma_max - 2R, where R = sigma_y + (1 - beta) H eps_p is the radius after loading and beta is the kinematic fraction (0 isotropic, 1 purely kinematic). Three fractions are solved in one script. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Explicit dynamics: element erosion by plastic-strain failure, uniform bar at finite strain | Explicit dynamics (failure and element erosion) | A uniform steel bar is stretched until the accumulated plastic strain reaches the failure value 0.3. The explicit solver (finite-strain updated Lagrangian formulation) removes the element at the moment the criterion is met; the displacement of the driven face… show full textA uniform steel bar is stretched until the accumulated plastic strain reaches the failure value 0.3. The explicit solver (finite-strain updated Lagrangian formulation) removes the element at the moment the criterion is met; the displacement of the driven face at that moment is compared with the closed form u_f = L(exp(eps_fail + sigma_f/E) - 1) inside a +-0.5 % window. The erosion energy of one element is compared with a numerical integral of the work per unit true strain, and the energy balance (kinetic + internal + erosion energy against the work of the driven face) must close within 1 %. The mass of an eroded element stays on its nodes. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.46% |
| Explicit dynamics: HEX8 cantilever under self-weight (Euler-Bernoulli) | Explicit dynamics (HEX8 bending) | A slender cantilever (span/height 20) is meshed with 8 layers of one-point HEX8 elements through the thickness and loaded by its own weight applied as a step. The time average of the tip deflection over four fundamental periods equals the static deflection of… show full textA slender cantilever (span/height 20) is meshed with 8 layers of one-point HEX8 elements through the thickness and loaded by its own weight applied as a step. The time average of the tip deflection over four fundamental periods equals the static deflection of a linear system under a step load; it is compared with the Euler-Bernoulli value plus the Timoshenko shear term. The energy of the hourglass control must stay below 10 % of the internal energy (with a single layer the bending is carried by the hourglass control alone and the solver warns). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.7% |
| Explicit dynamics: longitudinal wave speed in a HEX8 bar | Explicit dynamics (wave propagation) | A velocity step travels along a 1 m steel bar meshed with 100 one-point HEX8 elements. The wave speed is found from the arrival times of the half-height of the front at two sections and compared with the 1D bar speed sqrt(E/rho). Poisson ratio is zero, so the… show full textA velocity step travels along a 1 m steel bar meshed with 100 one-point HEX8 elements. The wave speed is found from the arrival times of the half-height of the front at two sections and compared with the 1D bar speed sqrt(E/rho). Poisson ratio is zero, so the 3D element sound speed sqrt((K + 4/3 G)/rho) equals the bar speed. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Explicit dynamics: Johnson-Cook strain-rate sensitivity (copper) | Explicit dynamics (material model) | Stress at 2 % plastic strain of OFHC copper at two strain rates, 10 and 1000 1/s, with reference rate 10 1/s. The ratio must equal the Johnson-Cook rate factor 1 + C ln(1000/10). The explicit solver uses the instantaneous plastic strain rate of the step (an im… show full textStress at 2 % plastic strain of OFHC copper at two strain rates, 10 and 1000 1/s, with reference rate 10 1/s. The ratio must equal the Johnson-Cook rate factor 1 + C ln(1000/10). The explicit solver uses the instantaneous plastic strain rate of the step (an implicit-Euler viscoplastic law); a step-count study shows the result does not depend on the time step. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.04% |
| Explicit dynamics: multilinear hardening curve | Explicit dynamics (material model) | A three-segment tabulated hardening curve (plastic strain : stress) is followed by the explicit solver. The stress at three strains is compared with the curve evaluated at the plastic strain that satisfies eps = sigma/E + eps_p (found by bisection in the refer… show full textA three-segment tabulated hardening curve (plastic strain : stress) is followed by the explicit solver. The stress at three strains is compared with the curve evaluated at the plastic strain that satisfies eps = sigma/E + eps_p (found by bisection in the reference). | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Explicit dynamics: shock wave in copper, Mie-Gruneisen equation of state, Us = c0 + s Up | Explicit dynamics (shock waves) | A piston drives a velocity step Up into a confined copper bar. The volumetric response follows the Mie-Gruneisen equation of state on the shock adiabat (p = p_H (1 - Gamma0 eta/2) + Gamma0 rho0 e, p_H = rho0 c0^2 eta/(1 - s eta)^2), the deviatoric part is the… show full textA piston drives a velocity step Up into a confined copper bar. The volumetric response follows the Mie-Gruneisen equation of state on the shock adiabat (p = p_H (1 - Gamma0 eta/2) + Gamma0 rho0 e, p_H = rho0 c0^2 eta/(1 - s eta)^2), the deviatoric part is the elastic material kernel, artificial viscosity captures the front. The shock speed from the 0.5 Up arrival times at two geophones must equal c0 + s Up (Rankine-Hugoniot with the linear Us-Up fit); the compression behind the front must equal Up/Us (mass conservation). The script shows Up = 1500 m/s; the Up = 500 m/s run is executed by the runner. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.08% |
| Explicit dynamics: Taylor bar impact, convergence in the time step | Explicit dynamics (impact) | A steel bar hits a rigid wall at 150 m/s (the velocity is given to ALL nodes of the body, interior ones included). The mean plastic strain is computed at four time-step factors; the change between successive factors must shrink and the last one must stay withi… show full textA steel bar hits a rigid wall at 150 m/s (the velocity is given to ALL nodes of the body, interior ones included). The mean plastic strain is computed at four time-step factors; the change between successive factors must shrink and the last one must stay within 2 %. The earlier built-in explicit law grew the plastic strain 6-fold when the step was cut 16-fold, because it accumulated plastic strain once per step on a held strain. This is a convergence study, not a comparison with an experiment. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.04% |
| Explicit dynamics: Taylor impact of a copper cylinder, final length against the Hawkyard and Taylor theories | Explicit dynamics (impact) | A perfectly plastic copper cylinder hits a rigid wall at 91.5 m/s (rho U^2 / sigma = 0.25). The explicit solver in the finite-strain formulation is run until the cylinder comes to rest; the final length is compared with the energy-balance theory of Hawkyard an… show full textA perfectly plastic copper cylinder hits a rigid wall at 91.5 m/s (rho U^2 / sigma = 0.25). The explicit solver in the finite-strain formulation is run until the cylinder comes to rest; the final length is compared with the energy-balance theory of Hawkyard and the momentum theory of Taylor, both one-dimensional models evaluated numerically here. The cylinder cross-section is a square of the same area as the circle of the classical problem, since both theories depend on the area only. The kinetic energy of the impact must go into plastic work and the energy balance must close within 1 %. The result is a comparison with theory, not with a test. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.5% |
| Explicit dynamics: reflection of P and S waves from a Lysmer-Kuhlemeyer absorbing boundary | Explicit dynamics (waves in a continuum) | A Ricker pulse travels along a soil column to an absorbing boundary (viscous dashpots rho·c_p, rho·c_s of the adjacent element on every boundary face, treated implicitly in the time step). A geophone 450 m before the boundary records the incident and the refle… show full textA Ricker pulse travels along a soil column to an absorbing boundary (viscous dashpots rho·c_p, rho·c_s of the adjacent element on every boundary face, treated implicitly in the time step). A geophone 450 m before the boundary records the incident and the reflected pulse; the reflection coefficient is the ratio of their peak velocities. An ideal absorber gives 0; the discrete one is second-order small in the mesh step (0.4 % at 23-27 cells per wavelength), the target is at most 5 %. Oblique incidence is worse (45°: about 9 %, 60°: about 24 % in the C++ test), this card is the normal-incidence case. The script shows the P run; the S run is executed by the runner. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.39% |
| Explicit dynamics: P and S wave speeds in a soil column from virtual geophones | Explicit dynamics (waves in a continuum) | A Ricker pulse (15 Hz) pressure (P) or shear traction (S) is applied at the free end of a laterally confined soil column; an absorbing boundary closes the far end. Virtual geophones record particle velocity; the wave speed is the cross-correlation lag between… show full textA Ricker pulse (15 Hz) pressure (P) or shear traction (S) is applied at the free end of a laterally confined soil column; an absorbing boundary closes the far end. Virtual geophones record particle velocity; the wave speed is the cross-correlation lag between two geophones 800 m apart, compared with sqrt((K + 4/3 G)/rho) and sqrt(G/rho). The amplitude of the plane wave must equal p/(rho c_p) and tau/(rho c_s). The script shows the P run; the S run (shear traction, u_x = u_z = 0 rollers on the lateral faces, h = 1.25 m) is executed by the verification runner the same way. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.68% |
| Explicit dynamics: reflection and transmission of a P wave at a layer interface | Explicit dynamics (waves in a continuum) | A Ricker pulse crosses the interface between soil and a stiffer rock layer (and in a second run, a softer layer). The reflected and transmitted velocity amplitudes are compared with the impedance contrast: |R_v| = |Z1 - Z2|/(Z1 + Z2), T_v = 2 Z1/(Z1 + Z2), Z =… show full textA Ricker pulse crosses the interface between soil and a stiffer rock layer (and in a second run, a softer layer). The reflected and transmitted velocity amplitudes are compared with the impedance contrast: |R_v| = |Z1 - Z2|/(Z1 + Z2), T_v = 2 Z1/(Z1 + Z2), Z = rho c_p; the arrival time of the reflection must equal 2(x_i - x_g)/c_p. The script shows the stiff-layer run; the soft-layer run is executed by the runner. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.64% |
| Explicit dynamics: spherical P wave from a smooth point source, absolute amplitude and 1/r decay | Explicit dynamics (waves in a continuum) | A curl-free Gaussian body-force field (a smooth centre of expansion) radiates a pure P wave in an octant model with three symmetry planes and three absorbing faces. Peak radial displacement on the axis at four distances is compared with the closed-form exterio… show full textA curl-free Gaussian body-force field (a smooth centre of expansion) radiates a pure P wave in an octant model with three symmetry planes and three absorbing faces. Peak radial displacement on the axis at four distances is compared with the closed-form exterior field of the equivalent point source u_r = -Q/(4 pi M) [s'(tau)/(c r) + s(tau)/r^2], Q = A (2 pi)^{3/2} sigma^3, where the Ricker source function is filtered by the Fourier transform of the Gaussian (an equivalent Ricker with a_eff). The near-field term and the 1/r decay are included; nothing is fitted. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 4.59% |
| Explicit dynamics: Rayleigh surface wave speed in a half-space (Lamb problem) | Explicit dynamics (waves in a continuum) | A vertical Ricker force acts on the free surface of an elastic half-space (a plane-strain slab, one HEX8 element thick, absorbing right and bottom faces). The Rayleigh pulse is tracked by three surface geophones; the speed from the cross-correlation lag is com… show full textA vertical Ricker force acts on the free surface of an elastic half-space (a plane-strain slab, one HEX8 element thick, absorbing right and bottom faces). The Rayleigh pulse is tracked by three surface geophones; the speed from the cross-correlation lag is compared with the root of the Rayleigh equation (about 0.919 c_s for nu = 0.25) and with the engineering formula c_s(0.862 + 1.14 nu)/(1 + nu). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.31% |
| Harmonic response of cantilever beam (P2 Tet10) | Harmonic analysis | Frequency response and resonant tip amplitude of a prismatic cantilever beam under harmonic tip transverse load, verified against Euler-Bernoulli analytical modal frequency and single-degree-of-freedom resonance peak amplitude. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.23% |
| Harmonic response: load phase angles on a pinned beam (antiphase forces cancel a symmetric mode) | Harmonic analysis | Two equal transverse forces at L/4 and 3L/4 of a pinned beam. In phase they excite only the symmetric modes; in antiphase (phase 180°) the modal force of every symmetric mode is exactly zero and only the antisymmetric modes respond; with a 90° shift the first… show full textTwo equal transverse forces at L/4 and 3L/4 of a pinned beam. In phase they excite only the symmetric modes; in antiphase (phase 180°) the modal force of every symmetric mode is exactly zero and only the antisymmetric modes respond; with a 90° shift the first modal force is F·sin(π/4)·(1 + i). The responses are checked against the Euler-Bernoulli modal series with complex modal forces, and the two cancellations against zero. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.32% |
| Harmonic response: single-degree-of-freedom oscillator with Rayleigh damping | Harmonic analysis | A massless cantilever with a tip point mass is a single-degree-of-freedom oscillator. With Rayleigh damping C = αM + βK its modal damping ratio is ζ = (αm + βk)/(2mω₀) and the amplitude and phase of the forced response follow |H(ω)| = 1/√((k − mω²)² + (cω)²),… show full textA massless cantilever with a tip point mass is a single-degree-of-freedom oscillator. With Rayleigh damping C = αM + βK its modal damping ratio is ζ = (αm + βk)/(2mω₀) and the amplitude and phase of the forced response follow |H(ω)| = 1/√((k − mω²)² + (cω)²), φ = −atan2(cω, k − mω²) with c = αm + βk. The card checks the natural frequency, ζ, the amplitude and phase on nine frequencies, the position f₀√(1 − 2ζ²) and the height of the resonance peak. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.06% |
| Harmonic response: two-body cantilever with different Rayleigh coefficients (non-proportional damping) | Harmonic analysis | A steel and an aluminium half of a cantilever get different Rayleigh pairs (α, β), so the modal damping matrix Φᵀ(Σ α_r M_r + β_r K_r)Φ is not diagonal. The harmonic response from the full modal basis (a complex n×n system on every frequency) is compared with… show full textA steel and an aluminium half of a cantilever get different Rayleigh pairs (α, β), so the modal damping matrix Φᵀ(Σ α_r M_r + β_r K_r)Φ is not diagonal. The harmonic response from the full modal basis (a complex n×n system on every frequency) is compared with the direct solution of the complete complex system (K − ω²M + iωC)u = F assembled independently, including a 90° phase shift between two load groups. The error of truncated bases and the gap to the diagonal-only approximation of the same matrix are reported. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Longitudinal harmonic response of rod (P1 Tet4) | Harmonic analysis | Axial dynamic frequency response and resonance amplitude of a steel rod under longitudinal harmonic tensile force, verified against exact 1D continuous wave propagation velocity and analytical resonance amplification factor. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.03% |
| Nonlinear heat conduction: temperature-dependent conductivity κ(T) (Kirchhoff transform) | Nonlinear heat transfer | Steady heat conduction through a bar with linearly temperature-dependent conductivity κ(T) = κ₀(1 + βT) = 20·(1 + 0.01·T) W/(m·K) between 0 °C and 100 °C. While constant κ would yield 50 °C at mid-span, the exact Kirchhoff integral transform gives T(L/2) = 58.… show full textSteady heat conduction through a bar with linearly temperature-dependent conductivity κ(T) = κ₀(1 + βT) = 20·(1 + 0.01·T) W/(m·K) between 0 °C and 100 °C. While constant κ would yield 50 °C at mid-span, the exact Kirchhoff integral transform gives T(L/2) = 58.1139 °C. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Thermal contact conductance across a two-body interface | Nonlinear heat transfer | Two stacked blocks (10 × 10 × 10 mm each, k = 30 W/(m·K)) joined by an imperfect thermal contact interface with conductance h_c = 1000 W/(m²·K) under a 100 °C temperature difference. Verifies the interface temperature jump ΔT_c = q/h_c = 60 K, total heat trans… show full textTwo stacked blocks (10 × 10 × 10 mm each, k = 30 W/(m·K)) joined by an imperfect thermal contact interface with conductance h_c = 1000 W/(m²·K) under a 100 °C temperature difference. Verifies the interface temperature jump ΔT_c = q/h_c = 60 K, total heat transfer Q = 6.0 W, and body midpoint temperatures (90 °C and 10 °C). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Transient heat conduction: integral energy conservation under time-varying loads | Transient heat conduction | A steel bar subjected simultaneously to time-modulated Dirichlet wall temperature T_D(t), convective ambient temperature T_∞(t), and volumetric heat generation Q(t). Verifies exact discrete thermal energy conservation ΔU = E_gen + E_flux + E_dir − E_conv and t… show full textA steel bar subjected simultaneously to time-modulated Dirichlet wall temperature T_D(t), convective ambient temperature T_∞(t), and volumetric heat generation Q(t). Verifies exact discrete thermal energy conservation ΔU = E_gen + E_flux + E_dir − E_conv and time-interpolated probe histories. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 1.13% |
| Transient radiative cooling of a high-conductivity slab | Nonlinear heat transfer | Nonlinear transient cooling of a thermally lumped block (Bi ≪ 1) from T₀ = 900 °C over 600 s by Stefan–Boltzmann radiation (ε = 0.85) into a 20 °C ambient. Temperature at t = 600 s and cumulative radiated energy are verified against the exact radiative cooling… show full textNonlinear transient cooling of a thermally lumped block (Bi ≪ 1) from T₀ = 900 °C over 600 s by Stefan–Boltzmann radiation (ε = 0.85) into a 20 °C ambient. Temperature at t = 600 s and cumulative radiated energy are verified against the exact radiative cooling ODE ρ·c_p·L·dT/dt = −εσ(T⁴ − T_∞⁴). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Hybrid mesh: patch test across a welded wedge/tet interface | Meshing / hybrid hex + tet zones | A bar in uniform tension with a layer of three wedge layers on its clamped end face (refine inflate) welded to the tetrahedral rest. A constant stress field is representable exactly by every element type, so any mixed mesh that conforms at the interface must r… show full textA bar in uniform tension with a layer of three wedge layers on its clamped end face (refine inflate) welded to the tetrahedral rest. A constant stress field is representable exactly by every element type, so any mixed mesh that conforms at the interface must reproduce σxx = σ and σyy = σzz = 0 in every node to rounding level. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Hybrid mesh: hex-layer zone on a hole wall, stress concentration of a finite-width plate | Meshing / hybrid hex + tet zones | A plate with a central hole under uniform tension. A layer of structured elements (4 wedge layers, graded towards the wall) is built on the hole surface (refine tube), the rest of the body is tetrahedra; the layer is welded to the tet mesh through shared nodes… show full textA plate with a central hole under uniform tension. A layer of structured elements (4 wedge layers, graded towards the wall) is built on the hole surface (refine tube), the rest of the body is tetrahedra; the layer is welded to the tet mesh through shared nodes. The peak stress at the hole edge is compared with the Peterson/Howland finite-width correction of the Kirsch solution. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 2.3% |
| Hybrid mesh: shrink fit, hex-layer zone on the hub bore (Lamé) | Meshing / hybrid hex + tet zones, contact interface | A solid shaft pressed into a hub with a radial interference. The hub carries a welded wedge layer at its bore (the contact surface); shaft and hub are independent meshes tied node-to-surface with the interference as the right-hand side. In plane strain with id… show full textA solid shaft pressed into a hub with a radial interference. The hub carries a welded wedge layer at its bore (the contact surface); shaft and hub are independent meshes tied node-to-surface with the interference as the right-hand side. In plane strain with identical materials the contact pressure is uniform and the hub bore hoop stress is given by Lamé; the tied interface is exactly equivalent to frictionless contact here (the contact is closed and sticks by symmetry). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 2.54% |
| Kirchhoff-Mindlin circular plate under uniform transverse pressure | Static | Bending of a clamped circular plate under uniform transverse pressure. The analytical benchmark combines the classical Kirchhoff thin-plate flexural solution with the Mindlin first-order shear deformation correction (Reissner-Mindlin plate theory). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.09% |
| Lamé thick cylinder in rigid casing | Static | Stress and radial displacement distribution in a thick-walled cylinder under internal pressure with outer surface constrained along its surface normal (rigid casing, ur(b) = 0). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.48% |
| MacNeal-Harder rectangular plate | Static (shells) | Rectangular plate/shell benchmark family with aspect ratios 1 and 5, in simply-supported and clamped variants, under either uniform pressure or a concentrated center load. Center-point deflection is compared against a normalized coefficient table, making this… show full textRectangular plate/shell benchmark family with aspect ratios 1 and 5, in simply-supported and clamped variants, under either uniform pressure or a concentrated center load. Center-point deflection is compared against a normalized coefficient table, making this a classical check against plate-bending locking and load-application errors. | MacNeal–Harder benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.83% |
| NAFEMS FV12 | Modal analysis | Free thin square plate with in-plane motion constrained — rigid-body mode filtering and repeated eigenvalues in shell elements. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 1.44% |
| NAFEMS FV13 | Modal analysis | Simply-supported thin square plate — out-of-plane bending modes with repeated eigenvalue pairs; the reference row is independently reproducible by the Navier closed-form solution. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 3.95% |
| NAFEMS FV15 | Modal analysis | Clamped thin rhombic (skew) plate — out-of-plane bending modes on a highly skewed planform; a stringent element-distortion check for plate bending. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 1.11% |
| NAFEMS FV16 | Modal analysis | Cantilevered thin square plate — shell modal and mass formulation test with a single fixed edge. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.66% |
| NAFEMS FV22 | Modal analysis | Clamped thick rhombic (skew) plate — Mindlin-regime bending modes (t/a = 0.1) on a highly skewed planform; checks transverse-shear behavior on distorted elements. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 2.98% |
| NAFEMS FV4 | Modal analysis | Cantilever beam with off-centre tip point masses — bending-torsion coupling and closely spaced eigenvalues. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 1.06% |
| NAFEMS FV52 | Modal analysis | Simply-supported solid square plate — normal modes of a solid (brick) plate model, first three modes are rigid-body/near-zero. | NAFEMS FV benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 4.22% |
| NAFEMS LE2 | Static (shells) | Cylindrical shell bending patch under an applied edge moment — outer-surface tangential (hoop) stress check; the target equals the closed form 6M/t^2 exactly. | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.02% |
| NAFEMS LE5 | Static | Z-section cantilever under torsion — axial (warping) stress check near the fixed end. | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 4.66% |
| NAFEMS LE6 | Static (shells) | Skew plate under uniform normal pressure — principal stress check near a corner singularity. | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 1.65% |
| NAFEMS LE7 | Static (shells) | Axisymmetric thin-walled cylinder/sphere pressure vessel — axial stress check on the outer surface. | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 3.4% |
| NAFEMS LE8 | Static (shells) | Axisymmetric shell under internal pressure — hoop stress check away from the boundary. | NAFEMS LE benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 4.35% |
| NAFEMS T1 | Thermomechanical | Membrane with a circular hot spot — steady-state thermoelastic stress at the spot boundary; the target is independently reproducible by the circular-inclusion closed form sigma = E*alpha*dT/2. | NAFEMS thermal benchmark suite | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.65% |
| NAFEMS T2: steady-state conduction with nonlinear Stefan–Boltzmann radiation | Nonlinear heat transfer | One-dimensional steady heat conduction along a bar whose hot end is held at 1000 K (726.85 °C) and whose cold end radiates to a 300 K (26.85 °C) environment with emissivity ε = 0.98. Solved via full Newton–Raphson with the exact 4εσT³ radiation Jacobian and co… show full textOne-dimensional steady heat conduction along a bar whose hot end is held at 1000 K (726.85 °C) and whose cold end radiates to a 300 K (26.85 °C) environment with emissivity ε = 0.98. Solved via full Newton–Raphson with the exact 4εσT³ radiation Jacobian and compared against the NAFEMS T2 reference temperature of 927 K (653.85 °C). | NAFEMS thermal benchmark suite | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| NAFEMS T4 | Heat transfer | Two-dimensional steady-state heat conduction with convective boundary conditions — temperature check at an edge point, solved as an exact 3D extrusion equivalent. | NAFEMS thermal benchmark suite | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.31% |
| Post-buckling — Cylinder All Modes | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: multimode imperfection interaction. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.31% |
| Post-buckling — Cylinder Mode1 | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: single-mode imperfection sensitivity. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.11% |
| Post-buckling — Deep Arch | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: multiple limit points in a hinged deep circular arch. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Post-buckling — Elastoplastic Beam | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: material yielding coupled to geometric instability. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.15% |
| Post-buckling — Hinged Cyl Section | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: snap-through of a thick cylindrical section. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 3.55% |
| Post-buckling — Plate Imperfection Sweep | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: imperfection sensitivity and branch selection. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.14% |
| Post-buckling — Square Plate Critical | Buckling | Bifurcation, imperfection sensitivity, and post-buckling path verification. Checks: plate bifurcation load and mode shape. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 0.79% |
| Contact — Cam Follower Kinematic Lift & Hertz Contact Stress | Contact | Eccentric cam mechanism with roller follower: kinematic stroke/lift s(phi) verification and Hertz contact stress on cylinder-on-cylinder cam profile. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Cattaneo MINDLIN | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: central stick radius and annular microslip. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.2% |
| Contact — Coulomb Stick Slip | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: stick-slip transition and friction cone. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Disc Brake Caliper Clamping & Friction Torque | Contact | Two-sided disc brake caliper clamping contact: normal pad clamping force equilibrium and resulting friction braking torque. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Bolted Flange Joint Preload & Gasket Opening | Contact | Bolted high-pressure pipe flange joint: 8-bolt preload, internal fluid pressure separating force and contact sealing land compression. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Frictionless Slide | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: normal/tangential basis update during sliding. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.06% |
| Contact — Gap Spring | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: gap activation complementarity and reaction sign. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Involute Gear Mesh Torque Balance | Contact | Multi-step tooth contact in spur gear pair, torque transmission along line of action and torque leak gate. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Hertz Line | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: line contact pressure and force integration. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Inclined Block | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: friction threshold with changing contact basis. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Nonmatching Conservation | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: global conservation and mesh-bias sensitivity. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Open Close Cycle | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: active-set hysteresis bugs and release. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Pin Lug Clearance & Bearing Reaction | Contact | 3-body pin-lug-clevis connection under axial tension: reaction force equilibrium and peak contact bearing stress. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Planetary Gear Power Split & Torque Equilibrium | Contact | Multi-body planetary gear set (sun, 3 planets, fixed ring gear): multi-step tooth contact, uniform 3-way load sharing and global torque equilibrium. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Shaft-Hub Keyway Joint Shear & Bearing Stress | Contact | 3-body drive shaft, flanged hub and parallel key assembly under torsional loading: torque transmission, key shear stress tau_shear and keyway contact bearing stress sigma_bearing. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Shrink Fit | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: initial overclosure pressure and Lame stress field. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Contact — Uniform Patch | Contact | Unilateral, frictional, sliding, or interference-contact verification. Checks: constant pressure transmission and force conservation. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Creep — Bree Ratcheting | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: elastic shakedown reversed plasticity and ratcheting classification. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Creep — Burgers Step Load | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: instantaneous primary and steady creep in one history. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Creep — Kelvin Voigt | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: retarded creep under a stress step. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Creep — Maxwell Relaxation | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: Maxwell stress relaxation and exponential time integration. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Creep — NAFEMS Test10b | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: biaxial primary creep time and strain hardening. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 3.39% |
| Creep — Norton Constant Stress | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: steady creep power law and time units. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Creep — Norton Relaxation | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: stress relaxation under fixed total strain. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.2% |
| Creep — Perzyna Overstress | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: overstress threshold and rate exponent. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Creep — Standard Linear Solid | Creep | Time-dependent creep, relaxation, viscoelasticity, or viscoplasticity verification. Checks: instantaneous and long-term modulus separation. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Center Crack KI | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: mode-I stress intensity factor. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Cohesive Bilinear | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: damage initiation softening and complete decohesion. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Cohesive Mixed Mode | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: normal-shear initiation surface. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — DCB Beam Theory | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: mode-I compliance and energy release rate. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — DCB Mismatched Mesh | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: mesh mismatch and cohesive/VCCT consistency. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.09% |
| Damage and fracture — ENF Mode II | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: end-notched-flexure sliding crack growth. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Griffith Energy | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: KI-to-G conversion and plane-strain modulus. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Gurson Zero Porosity | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: zero-porosity reduction and hydrostatic sensitivity. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Damage and fracture — Paris Constant Dk | Damage and fracture | Damage, cohesive-zone, fracture-mechanics, or crack-growth verification. Checks: cycle integration and units in Paris law. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Duffing Energy | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: nonlinear restoring force and conservative integration. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Elastic Collision | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: impulse momentum and elastic impact. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Elastic Pendulum Bathe | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: coupled axial and pendular oscillation. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Pendulum 90 Period | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: amplitude-dependent pendulum period. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Pendulum Energy | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: long-time energy conservation and phase error. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Restitution Impact | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: coefficient of restitution and impulse sign. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Rigid Free Flight | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: free-flight momentum energy and center-of-mass trajectory. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Rotating Cylinder | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: large rotation with elastoplastic strain hardening. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear dynamics — Symmetric Top | Nonlinear dynamics | Transient nonlinear dynamics, impact, and conservation-law verification. Checks: Euler-angle precession nutation and spin. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Elastica Tip Force | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: dead-load direction large-deflection elastica. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.74% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Euler Column Bifurcation | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: initial-stress stiffness and bifurcation load. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.08% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Lee Frame | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: multiple limit and displacement-limit points. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.49% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — NAFEMS 3dnlg5 | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: large deflection of curved cantilever. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.29% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Pure Moment Full Loop | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: rotation accumulation beyond 2pi and orientation update. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Pure Moment Quarter Circle | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: finite rotation kinematics and moment control. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.05% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Rigid Rotation Objectivity | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: frame indifference under large rigid rotation. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Geometric nonlinearity — Snap Truss | Static (geometric NL) | Large-displacement and large-rotation equilibrium-path verification. Checks: limit point snap-through and negative tangent. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.04% |
| Hyperelasticity — Arruda Boyce Uniaxial | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: five-term chain-locking series. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Hyperelasticity — MMS Finite Strain | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: implementation order of accuracy. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.56% |
| Hyperelasticity — Neohookean Equibiaxial | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: equibiaxial constitutive response. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Hyperelasticity — Neohookean Planar | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: planar tension pure-shear mode. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Hyperelasticity — Neohookean Simple Shear | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: finite simple shear and normal-stress effect. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Hyperelasticity — Neohookean Uniaxial | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: uniaxial finite strain and pressure elimination. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Hyperelasticity — Objectivity | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: frame indifference and energy invariance. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Hyperelasticity — Ogden Uniaxial | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: Ogden exponent and nominal-stress convention. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.02% |
| Hyperelasticity — Treloar Data | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: fit quality across deformation modes. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
| Hyperelasticity — Yeoh Uniaxial | Hyperelastic | Finite-strain hyperelastic response and objectivity verification. Checks: higher-order invariant terms. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.02% |
| Plasticity — J2 Hydrostatic Invariance | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: deviatoric split and pressure-independent yielding. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — J2 Multi Element Patch | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: plastic constitutive integration plus assembly. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — J2 Pure Shear | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: J2 invariants and engineering shear convention. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — J2 Reverse Yield | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: reverse loading without unintended kinematic hardening. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — J2 Rotation Objectivity | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: stress and history rotation covariance. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.57% |
| Plasticity — J2 Uniaxial Monotonic | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: yield detection and radial return. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — J2 Unload Residual | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: elastic unloading and history variables. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — NAFEMS R0026 Suite | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: ten small-strain ductile-metal assembly tests. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Plasticity — Nonproportional Plate | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: nonproportional return mapping and unloading history. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Plasticity — Plastic Hinge Rect | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: first yield and fully plastic moment. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.05% |
| Plasticity — Prager Hodge Cylinder | Plasticity | Plastic constitutive integration, history variables, and structural limit-load verification. Checks: large-strain incompressible plastic flow. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear solver — Arclength Snap Truss | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: path following through load limit points. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.04% |
| Nonlinear solver — Contact Active Set | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: activation release and no cycling. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Shell element | PASS · 1.42% |
| Nonlinear solver — Energy Balance | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: external work internal energy and contact work accounting. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear solver — Load Reversal | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: trial-state rollback after rejected steps and reversed loading. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.02% |
| Nonlinear solver — Mixed Assembly Ladder | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: feature interaction without losing local verification. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam + Shell | PASS · 0.83% |
| Nonlinear solver — Scalar Newton | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: Newton update convergence order and stopping criteria. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Nonlinear solver — Singular Tangent Diagnostic | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: limit-point singularity and underconstraint distinction. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear solver — Step Size Independence | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: history integration and converged-path independence. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Nonlinear solver — Tangent Finite Difference | Nonlinear solver | Nonlinear iteration, tangent, path-following, and state-management verification. Checks: residual/Jacobian consistency. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Staged analysis: a body born on a loaded structure carries nothing | Birth and death of elements (staged analysis) | A 500 × 500 × 1000 mm block is compressed by a face pressure; a second block is then cast against its side face (born) while the load stays the same. The new body takes the deformed configuration of the first as its stress-free reference, so it stays unstresse… show full textA 500 × 500 × 1000 mm block is compressed by a face pressure; a second block is then cast against its side face (born) while the load stays the same. The new body takes the deformed configuration of the first as its stress-free reference, so it stays unstressed and the first block keeps carrying the whole load. An ordinary analysis with both blocks present from the start would let the glued side face share the load. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Staged construction: a column built in layers under its own weight | Birth and death of elements (staged analysis) | A 4 m column is erected as four stacked 1 m layers (separate bodies). Each layer is born stress-free on the already settled configuration of the layers below and carries its own weight from then on; the soft-element algorithm keeps unborn layers in the mesh at… show full textA 4 m column is erected as four stacked 1 m layers (separate bodies). Each layer is born stress-free on the already settled configuration of the layers below and carries its own weight from then on; the soft-element algorithm keeps unborn layers in the mesh at 1e-6 of their stiffness. On every stage the settlement of the column equals the closed form for a column of the current height, and the displacements are cumulative from stage to stage. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.12% |
| Staged excavation: removing layers of a loaded column — elastic rebound | Birth and death of elements (staged analysis) | A 3 m column stands under its own weight; its top layer is excavated (the body dies), then the next one. The force each dying body exerted on the rest is released gradually inside the stage, and the lower bodies rebound: the displacements after each excavation… show full textA 3 m column stands under its own weight; its top layer is excavated (the body dies), then the next one. The force each dying body exerted on the rest is released gradually inside the stage, and the lower bodies rebound: the displacements after each excavation equal the closed form for the shorter column, i.e. the process is elastically reversible. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0.17% |
| Staged analysis with plasticity: yielding only in the body born later | Birth and death of elements (staged analysis) | Two cubes are stacked; the elastic body A (σy = 300 MPa) exists from the start, the weaker elastic-plastic body B (σy = 150 MPa, linear isotropic hardening) is born on stage 2. The face pressure on B exists in the model from the start but acts on B only once B… show full textTwo cubes are stacked; the elastic body A (σy = 300 MPa) exists from the start, the weaker elastic-plastic body B (σy = 150 MPa, linear isotropic hardening) is born on stage 2. The face pressure on B exists in the model from the start but acts on B only once B exists. Under uniaxial strain (rollers on the lateral faces) B yields and A stays elastic; the plastic strain and the displacements follow the closed form of J2 radial return. The born body starts with a clean plastic history. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Staged analysis: a single stage with every body active equals an ordinary static solve | Birth and death of elements (staged analysis) | Three stacked bodies are compressed by a face pressure. The same model is solved twice on the native solver: as an ordinary nonlinear static analysis and with one stage that activates nothing and kills nothing. The displacements and von Mises stresses must coi… show full textThree stacked bodies are compressed by a face pressure. The same model is solved twice on the native solver: as an ordinary nonlinear static analysis and with one stage that activates nothing and kills nothing. The displacements and von Mises stresses must coincide; a stage with every element active is not allowed to change the answer. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Adiabatic Plastic Heating | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: plastic-work conversion and unit consistency. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Bree Classification | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: thermal shakedown and ratcheting. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Parallel Bars | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: differential expansion force sharing. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Restrained Bar | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: thermal expansion sign and constrained stress. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Temperature Dependent E | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: property interpolation and evaluation temperature. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Temperature Dependent Yield | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: competition of thermal stress and decreasing yield strength. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Thermomechanics — Viscoelastic Damper | Thermomechanical | Coupled temperature, deformation, plasticity, and dissipation verification. Checks: hysteretic heating temperature shift and large deformation. | Published nonlinear verification benchmark | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Lekhnitskii (1963) §6 — 3D Orthotropic Solid Off-Axis Uniaxial Tension via Surface Normal Projection | 3D Anisotropic & Orthotropic Solid Mechanics (Ansys-Style Surface Coordinate Projection) | Verification of 3D orthotropic solid element orientation via Ansys-style guide surface normal projection and reference coordinate system tangent projection against S.G. Lekhnitskii's exact transformed compliance formula for off-axis uniaxial tension of a unidi… show full textVerification of 3D orthotropic solid element orientation via Ansys-style guide surface normal projection and reference coordinate system tangent projection against S.G. Lekhnitskii's exact transformed compliance formula for off-axis uniaxial tension of a unidirectional CFRP bar at θ = 30°. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Plate with hole (symmetry planes via normal constraints) | Static | Stress concentration factor (Kirsch problem) for a tensioned plate with a central hole, solved on a quarter-symmetry model using surface normal constraints (n·u = 0) vs full model. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 1.38% |
| Random Vibration — Miles Equation Cantilever PSD | Vibration and Random Dynamics | Verification of random vibration power spectral density (PSD) response against classical Miles' closed-form equation for a single-degree-of-freedom base-excited system. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.08% |
| Saint-Venant torsion of an elastic prismatic shaft | Static | Pure torsion of an elastic circular shaft fixed at one end and loaded by an axial torque at the free tip. Solved via Saint-Venant torsion theory where plane cross-sections remain planar (no out-of-plane warping for circular sections) and twist angle is linearl… show full textPure torsion of an elastic circular shaft fixed at one end and loaded by an axial torque at the free tip. Solved via Saint-Venant torsion theory where plane cross-sections remain planar (no out-of-plane warping for circular sections) and twist angle is linearly proportional to torque and length. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0% |
| Solid cantilever under a tip point force — length-convention consistency | Static | Closes a specific gap in the corpus: before 2026-07-29 every solid case was loaded by PRESSURE, and pressure on a solid is scale-invariant (delta/L = p/E), which masks a mixed length convention. A force given in newtons is not scale-invariant: geometry in mm w… show full textCloses a specific gap in the corpus: before 2026-07-29 every solid case was loaded by PRESSURE, and pressure on a solid is scale-invariant (delta/L = p/E), which masks a mixed length convention. A force given in newtons is not scale-invariant: geometry in mm with a modulus in Pa moves the deflection by exactly 1e6. The same physical problem is therefore solved twice — in mm/MPa/N and in m/Pa/N — and the two answers must agree after conversion. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 2.02% |
| Response spectrum of a cantilever beam: modal masses and base shear (Euler-Bernoulli) | Response spectrum analysis | Effective modal mass fractions of the first three bending modes of a slender cantilever, the base shear and the tip displacement combined by SRSS over the five bending modes of a piecewise-linear design spectrum, checked against the closed-form Euler-Bernoulli… show full textEffective modal mass fractions of the first three bending modes of a slender cantilever, the base shear and the tip displacement combined by SRSS over the five bending modes of a piecewise-linear design spectrum, checked against the closed-form Euler-Bernoulli modal participation (roots of cos·cosh = -1, integrals of the mode shapes). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.48% |
| Response spectrum: CQC for close frequencies (cantilever with a rotated section) | Response spectrum analysis | A cantilever whose section is rotated by 30° has two bending families with close frequencies (ratio 1.10) that are BOTH excited by a base motion along one global axis. The CQC base shear and tip displacement (components combined with their signs) are checked a… show full textA cantilever whose section is rotated by 30° has two bending families with close frequencies (ratio 1.10) that are BOTH excited by a base motion along one global axis. The CQC base shear and tip displacement (components combined with their signs) are checked against a hand calculation with the Der Kiureghian correlation; SRSS is reported alongside. The base shear differs between the rules by more than 5 %; the tip displacement magnitude does not, because the two families vibrate in orthogonal planes (the card states this rather than hiding it). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.08% |
| Response spectrum: single-degree-of-freedom oscillator under the SP 14.13330 spectrum | Response spectrum analysis | A massless cantilever with a tip point mass is a single-degree-of-freedom oscillator. Its period, spectral displacement u = Sa(T)/ω² and base shear V = m·Sa(T) under the SP 14.13330.2018 design spectrum (site intensity 8, soil category II) are checked against… show full textA massless cantilever with a tip point mass is a single-degree-of-freedom oscillator. Its period, spectral displacement u = Sa(T)/ω² and base shear V = m·Sa(T) under the SP 14.13330.2018 design spectrum (site intensity 8, soil category II) are checked against the closed-form values with k = 3EI/L³. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Beam element | PASS · 0.07% |
| Cut-boundary submodeling (P1 global -> P2 TET10 local) on Kirsch plate with central hole (Kt = 3.08) | Meshing / submodeling & adaptive h-refinement | Verifies the automated cut-boundary displacement submodeling (`submodel`) and Zienkiewicz-Zhu adaptive h-refinement (`refine adaptive`) workflow on a tensile plate with a central circular hole (Kirsch problem, finite width 2R/W = 0.10, analytical Kt = 3.08). A… show full textVerifies the automated cut-boundary displacement submodeling (`submodel`) and Zienkiewicz-Zhu adaptive h-refinement (`refine adaptive`) workflow on a tensile plate with a central circular hole (Kirsch problem, finite width 2R/W = 0.10, analytical Kt = 3.08). A coarse global P1 tetrahedral mesh (h = 6 mm, 3112 elements) severely underpredicts the peak stress at the hole rim (1.808 MPa vs 3.080 MPa, -41.3%). Extracting a local 32 x 32 x 4 mm submodel box around the hole, remeshing locally at h = 1.2 mm with quadratic P2 (TET10) elements (10085 elements), and projecting the global displacement field onto the 1920 cut-boundary nodes via barycentric tet interpolation with nearest-element projection fallback recovers the true physical concentration at the free hole rim: sigma_vM,max = 2.970 MPa (-3.57% deviation from closed-form 3.080 MPa). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 3.57% |
| Thermoelasticity: axially restrained bar under uniform ΔT = 80 K | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | A prismatic bar with roller-clamped ends (u_x = 0 on both end faces, free transverse Poisson expansion) starts at a uniform temperature T₀ = 100 °C above the stress-free reference T_ref = 20 °C (ΔT = 80 K). The dynamic solver initializes in static thermoelasti… show full textA prismatic bar with roller-clamped ends (u_x = 0 on both end faces, free transverse Poisson expansion) starts at a uniform temperature T₀ = 100 °C above the stress-free reference T_ref = 20 °C (ΔT = 80 K). The dynamic solver initializes in static thermoelastic equilibrium without spurious impact waves (kinetic energy < 10⁻²⁷ J) and reproduces the exact uniaxial thermal stress σ_xx = −E·α·ΔT = −192.00 MPa. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0% |
| Boley–Barber problem: thermally induced vibrations of a cantilever beam | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | A slender cantilever beam subjected to sudden surface heat flux q₀ on its top face undergoes coupled bending oscillations around the evolving quasi-static thermal curvature κ_T(t) because the thermal diffusion time τ_d = h²/a is comparable to the fundamental f… show full textA slender cantilever beam subjected to sudden surface heat flux q₀ on its top face undergoes coupled bending oscillations around the evolving quasi-static thermal curvature κ_T(t) because the thermal diffusion time τ_d = h²/a is comparable to the fundamental flexural period T₁ (Boley parameter B = T₁/τ_d = 1). Peak dynamic tip deflection is verified against the closed-form Euler–Bernoulli modal series. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.45% |
| Danilovskaya problem: dynamic thermoelastic stress wave in a half-space | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | Sudden boundary heating of an elastic half-space in uniaxial strain generates a longitudinal thermoelastic stress wave propagating at the dilatational wave speed c_p = √(E(1−ν)/(ρ(1+ν)(1−2ν))) with a compressive precursor ahead of the wavefront x = c_p·t and a… show full textSudden boundary heating of an elastic half-space in uniaxial strain generates a longitudinal thermoelastic stress wave propagating at the dilatational wave speed c_p = √(E(1−ν)/(ρ(1+ν)(1−2ν))) with a compressive precursor ahead of the wavefront x = c_p·t and a stress jump Δσ_xx = βT₀ across the wavefront. Verified against Danilovskaya's (1950) exact closed-form solution. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 1.72% |
| Gough–Joule piezocaloric effect: adiabatic thermoelastic heating under compression | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | Two-way thermoelastic coupling (u → T) via the dilatation-rate heat source q = −T_ref·β·tr(ε̇), where β = Eα/(1−2ν). Under adiabatic confined compression of a steel cube, the temperature rise scales linearly with volumetric strain ΔT = −(T_ref·β/(ρc_p))·tr(ε)… show full textTwo-way thermoelastic coupling (u → T) via the dilatation-rate heat source q = −T_ref·β·tr(ε̇), where β = Eα/(1−2ν). Under adiabatic confined compression of a steel cube, the temperature rise scales linearly with volumetric strain ΔT = −(T_ref·β/(ρc_p))·tr(ε) (doubling the compressive force doubles ΔT, distinguishing true piezocaloric coupling from quadratic elastic work). | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.01% |
| Coupled thermoelasticity: quasi-static vs dynamic response under slow and rapid heating | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | A cantilever beam heated on its top face by a smooth C² ramp 10s³ − 15s⁴ + 6s⁵ over R = 12 fundamental periods T₁ shows negligible inertial amplification, so dynamic Newmark integration (Mode B) matches quasi-static thermoelasticity (Mode A) within 0.57 %. Con… show full textA cantilever beam heated on its top face by a smooth C² ramp 10s³ − 15s⁴ + 6s⁵ over R = 12 fundamental periods T₁ shows negligible inertial amplification, so dynamic Newmark integration (Mode B) matches quasi-static thermoelasticity (Mode A) within 0.57 %. Conversely, under rapid heating (R = 0.5·T₁), inertial effects amplify the peak deflection by 45.9 %. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · 0.57% |
| Coupled nonlinear radiation & κ(T) in transient thermoelasticity (TD2 × T4) | Coupled transient thermoelasticity | Coupled transient thermoelasticity driven by nonlinear Stefan–Boltzmann surface radiation (εσ(T⁴ − T_∞⁴)) and temperature-dependent conductivity κ(T). Verifies that the Newton–θ thermal marcher inside the thermoelastic transient solver reproduces the standalon… show full textCoupled transient thermoelasticity driven by nonlinear Stefan–Boltzmann surface radiation (εσ(T⁴ − T_∞⁴)) and temperature-dependent conductivity κ(T). Verifies that the Newton–θ thermal marcher inside the thermoelastic transient solver reproduces the standalone nonlinear thermal transient solution to machine precision and induces the corresponding thermal stress state. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | — | PASS · <0.01% |
| Uniaxial tension, material sensitivity (aluminum) | Static | Same geometry and load as the steel uniaxial tension case, aluminum instead of steel (E = 70 GPa) — verifies that the elastic modulus is correctly propagated to displacement (elongation scales as 1/E) while stress stays independent of the material in this stat… show full textSame geometry and load as the steel uniaxial tension case, aluminum instead of steel (E = 70 GPa) — verifies that the elastic modulus is correctly propagated to displacement (elongation scales as 1/E) while stress stays independent of the material in this statically determinate loading. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · 0.64% |
| Uniaxial tension (steel) | Static | Stress recovery (von Mises, principal stresses) for a prismatic steel bar under uniform axial tension, checked away from the fixed-end boundary layer. | Classical analytical solution | 5% | Solid element | PASS · <0.01% |
Only public benchmark references are listed here. PASS/FAIL means a real solver run compared with the published reference; "In development" means the public case is cataloged but has not been run yet.